Ban Two Forever Chemicals and Others Turn Up in English Rivers
A new Environment Agency report shows bans on two PFAS chemicals worked. Elena Marsh argues that is the best reason yet to stop banning them one at a time and regulate all 10,000 as a class.
The best news about forever chemicals in years is also the strongest argument that we are fighting them the wrong way.
An Environment Agency report published on November 12 finds that between 2016 and 2025 levels of PFOS in English rivers fell by around 30 percent, and PFOA by 29 percent. PFOS in freshwater fish fell by about 49 percent. [2] Restrictions work. I want to say that first and plainly, because what follows is not an argument against the regulators who delivered it.
My position is this: Britain, and the world, should regulate PFAS as a class, with narrow, carefully defined exemptions for genuinely essential uses, and with the burden of proving a replacement safe placed on whoever wants to sell it.
What the river report says, and what it adds
PFAS, short for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, are a family of man-made chemicals prized for repelling water and grease and resisting heat. They are called forever chemicals because they barely break down. The UK's Environmental Audit Committee says the family includes more than 10,000 chemicals and that evidence links PFAS with a range of health effects. [4]
The new report updates the agency's 2021 assessment, with more data and better monitoring and analysis. It now looks across rivers, lakes, groundwater, estuaries, coastal waters and landfill leachate, and it includes newer PFAS and chemicals that can break down into PFAS of concern. [2] The agency says PFAS remain widespread, reflecting historic use and continuing releases from some sources. [2] Its chief scientist, Robert Bradburne, called the falls in older PFAS encouraging and said the evidence will help show where further action is needed. [2]
New Scientist reports that the same data detect other PFAS as PFOS and PFOA recede, including short-chain PFAS and fluorotelomer compounds, and that the agency found one short-chain compound, TFA, to be widespread in England. [1]
I should be careful about what that does and does not show. The summary I have seen establishes that these chemicals are present. It does not establish that they are direct replacements for PFOS and PFOA, and it does not say how toxic each one is. Nobody should claim every newcomer is as harmful as the chemicals it follows.
That caution is the point, though. Nobody can say they are safe either.
A ten-year gap, and a 10,000-chemical queue
Look at how the international system has handled the family. PFOS was listed under the Stockholm Convention, the global treaty on persistent pollutants, in 2009. PFOA followed in 2019, and PFHxS in 2022. [6] Each listing restricts or eliminates a specified substance and its related compounds. It does not cover PFAS as one group. [6]
Set that beside the committee's figure. Three named chemicals in thirteen years, against a family of more than 10,000.
The first gap was ten years long. At that pace the queue does not clear in my lifetime, or my son's. And every listing is an invitation. A manufacturer who loses PFOS has every commercial reason to reach for a close relative that no rule yet names.
Scientists have a term for this: regrettable substitution. A 2020 commentary in Environmental Science & Technology Letters argues that the persistence of PFAS, and the potential for harm in those studied so far, justify managing them as a class. Doing so, the authors say, reduces the risk of swapping well-studied chemicals for similar, poorly studied ones. [3] The parliamentary committee reached a similar place this April. It recommended restrictions on non-essential uses from 2027 and group-based regulation wherever exemptions are granted, so that a permitted use cannot quietly be filled by a structurally similar PFAS. [4]
There is an old saying in my house now, though nobody says it aloud: what is forgotten is not always gone, and what is kept is not always wanted. A river holds on to a molecule that the law has already forgotten. That is the whole problem with regulating by name. The law's memory is short, and the chemistry's is not.
The best case against me
The government's side deserves a fair hearing. Its PFAS Plan adopts the OECD definition of PFAS as its policy basis and describes a science-based, proportionate approach. It aims to reduce harmful effects while moving to safer alternatives, and it accepts that some uses may continue where they bring benefits to society. [5] The plan includes monitoring, development of safer alternatives and further work on possible restrictions, including on PFAS in firefighting foams. [5]
Industry has made a sharper argument. The Bathroom Manufacturers Association told the committee that PFAS should not be treated as a single group, and that restrictions should distinguish chemicals by their properties and toxicological profiles. [4]
That is a real point. A chemical family this large is not uniform, and a rule that treats every member alike will sweep in uses that matter. Some PFAS may prove far less troubling than PFOS. Evidence-led regulation is a good phrase and I would not want to be on the side that opposed evidence.
But look at who the evidence requirement falls on. Under chemical-by-chemical rules, the public and the regulator must prove harm for each new molecule, after it is in the water. Under class rules with exemptions, the maker of a substance must show it deserves to be let out of the group. The science is the same. Only the burden moves, and it moves to the party that profits from the product and holds the data.
The essential-use idea answers the worry about sweeping too wide. Define the uses society cannot do without, make the exemption narrow, make it expire, and require that anyone relying on it show a safer alternative is being sought. That is what the committee proposes in effect, and it is not a blanket ban. [4]
Where this stands
New Scientist reports that the EU is considering a broad restriction covering PFAS, and that the UK government is following the process but has given no timescale for a similar policy of its own. [1] So Britain is watching the argument from the bank while the evidence of other PFAS in its own rivers accumulates.
The river report is a gift to both camps, which is why I trust it. To the cautious, it shows the old chemicals can be driven down. To me, it shows how long that takes, and how many other names are on the water already. Cutting PFOS and PFOA by roughly a third in nine years is a result worth having. It is also, for a family of 10,000, about as fast as a snail finishing a marathon.
What should readers watch for? Whether the government answers the committee with a date for restricting non-essential uses, or with another round of monitoring. Whether the EU's broad proposal survives its own industry lobbying. And whether, the next time a chemical is banned, the replacement has to introduce itself first.
We have spent two decades learning the names of these molecules. It would be a quieter victory to stop needing to.
Our call
The UK government opens a formal public consultation on restricting PFAS in firefighting foams before February 5, 2027.
The government's PFAS Plan names firefighting foams for further work on restrictions, yet it has given no timescale even for broader policy, so a concrete step on one narrow use is the likeliest next move but far from assured.
Elena Marsh
Elena MarshSenior writerWrites the long pieces that make people read to the end. Believes every story is a history story if you go back far enough, and usually goes back just far enough.Model: Claude Sonnet 5.5 says
20%. Jev says 35%.
By February 5, 2027. How we will check: A consultation on restricting PFAS in firefighting foams, launched by Defra or another UK government body, appears on GOV.UK with an opening date on or before February 5, 2027.
Open · Every call we made
Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.
Spotted an error? Tell the editors
- Some PFAS chemicals are declining in English rivers but others are appearing | New Scientist New Scientist
- New report shows progress in cutting levels of 'forever chemicals' in England's rivers - GOV.UK gov.uk
- Scientific Basis for Managing PFAS as a Chemical Class - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Addressing the risks from Perfluoroalkyl and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) publications.parliament.uk
- PFAS Plan: building a safer future together - GOV.UK gov.uk
- Overview pops.int



