'Post-cozy' Game Sold a Third of Its Target, Maker Says
Melos Han-Tani published the full numbers behind his game Danchi Days, which sold a third of what he hoped. They show how far a pile of Steam wishlists can sit from the money that keeps a small studio going.
A game that 55,000 people had said they wanted sold about 1,500 copies on PC in its first week, and its maker has now published the numbers to explain why. [4]
Melos Han-Tani, whose studio Analgesic Productions self-publishes, posted a postmortem for Danchi Days on November 8. The game launched on Steam on October 29 with about 55,000 outstanding wishlists, drawn from about 60,000 total wishlist adds. His target was at least 5,000 copies in week one. He got roughly a third of that. [4][5]
A wishlist is a button on a Steam game page. Press it and the game is saved to your list, and Steam tells you when it launches or goes on sale. It costs the player nothing and commits them to nothing. That is the whole problem, and Han-Tani's postmortem is an unusually honest look at it.
My reading is this. The wishlist total is the most visible number in indie development and the least reliable. Han-Tani's own data shows that the same button, pressed in different months and for different reasons, meant very different things. And his game's look promised one kind of experience while its design delivered another, so many of the people who pressed the button were never going to buy what he made.
The funnel, in numbers
Han-Tani reported a first-week wishlist conversion rate of 2.2%, meaning the share of wishlisters who bought in the launch week. He had expected 6-7%, partly on the evidence of Angeline Era, the studio's earlier success, and his other games had seen first-week rates of 6-10%. [4]
The sharper finding is in his cohort breakdown. Wishlists added in September 2024, when the game was announced, converted at 7.4%. Wishlists added in July 2026 converted at 1.0%. [4]
That is a gap of more than seven to one inside a single game. The count on the dashboard treated both groups as equal, and the sales did not.
Han-Tani cautions that Steam does not show deletions by cohort, so his calculations slightly understate how well each cohort converted. The direction of the finding holds either way. [4]
Interest that was not intent
Most of the wishlists came from showcases, the curated online events where hundreds of upcoming games compete for a few seconds of attention. Reddit ads supplied another 10-15% of the total, and Han-Tani says they were expensive to acquire. He judges both sources to have converted worse than the announcement-period wishlists. [4]
Think of it as two crowds. One is the people who found the game early, looked at it properly and chose to follow it. The other is the people who tapped a button while scrolling past, or who were nudged by an ad. Both show up as the same line on the chart. The studio read the aggregate as stronger demand than it was.
Slow growth in Steam followers was another warning sign, Han-Tani says. Followers are people who chose to watch the studio, not just one game page, and that number was not keeping pace with the wishlists. [4]
He is also frank about what better marketing could have done. A stronger social-media plan might have lifted conversion from 2.2% to 3%, in his estimate, but he does not think it would have fixed the underlying problem. [4]
A cozy coat on an uncozy game
That underlying problem is legibility, and it is the most interesting part of the postmortem.
Danchi Days is a five-chapter adventure about a girl trying to revive her neighborhood's summer festival, with themes that include aging and dementia. Steam describes a game about exploring, talking, looking, sensing and reading, with no combat, farming, money, quest logs or time pressure. [1][5] Han-Tani calls it "post-cozy" and has described it as a fusion of dialogue, exploration, an in-game internet and tactile minigames meant to work together rather than a conventional genre. [2][4]
The art, though, looks like the cozy games that sell well. A player who sees soft colors and a small neighborhood expects the familiar loop of planting, earning and ticking through a quest list. Danchi Days has none of that. Han-Tani says he overestimated interest in a game with cozy visual and narrative cues but few of the standard cozy mechanics. [4]
Here the wishlist and the sale part ways. A wishlist records a reaction to a picture. A purchase needs the buyer to believe they understand what they are getting. When the picture suggests one game and the design is another, interest can be real and still not turn into money.
Han-Tani does not take the conventional lesson from this. He says he does not regret the art style, the genre or the narrative direction, and argues that it would be a loss for storytelling and games if creators could not use familiar aesthetics to tell stories outside established genres. [1][4] I think that is right as a statement about art. It is also compatible with a harder commercial truth: a work can break the rules on purpose and still owe the shopper a clear picture before the checkout.
His own fix points that way. Future marketing will put mechanics up front, including quest design and how talking to neighbors works, so that people can see what kind of game it is. [1][4]
The cost of being wrong
Han-Tani forecasts about 5,000 PC copies in the first year and about 10,000 copies over three years. He says that after development time, marketing and ad spend, localization, Steam's cut and sale prices, the game is unlikely to earn back its roughly $200,000 in development costs. [4]
The studio will survive. Han-Tani says the shortfall is not expected to threaten Analgesic Productions because Angeline Era did well and the studio publishes its own games. Danchi Days was funded by that earlier game and by savings. [4]
That detail matters. Most small teams have no earlier hit to absorb a miss. The postmortem reads as a warning partly because its author is among the better placed to take the blow, and the figures are still this bleak.
Switch and PlayStation versions are planned. Han-Tani expects them probably to break even only over the long run. [1][4]
How far the lesson travels
The obvious objection is that this is one game, and one developer's reading of his own numbers. That is fair. Han-Tani's account is a firsthand case study, not a controlled test of Steam, and his belief that showcase and ad wishlists converted worse is his judgment from the cohort data, not something Steam itself reports. [4]
The wider data offers a loose backing and an honest warning. GameDiscoverCo, a firm that analyzes Steam releases, looked at games launched between September 2024 and September 2025.
Among those with more than 25,000 launch wishlists, the median ratio was 0.15 first-week sales per wishlist. For games priced above $10 it fell to 0.10. [3]
Against that, 2.2% looks very low. The comparison is not exact, since the study estimates its ratio and Han-Tani measures conversion in his own way. GameDiscoverCo's analyst also warned that results varied by 10 to 20 times between games and that wishlist-to-sales ratios are an imperfect forecasting tool. [3]
The two sources agree on the one thing that matters. A wishlist count is not a forecast. If outcomes can differ by an order of magnitude, a studio that plans its finances on the headline number is betting on the luckiest end of the range.
The postmortem does not prove that showcases or ads fill the funnel with weak interest everywhere. Nobody has shown that, and the data in hand cannot. It does show that a developer can only find out by splitting his wishlists by source and date, which most of the people who rely on the number never do.
What it means for the market
The platforms sell discovery. Showcases, ads and algorithmic placement all promise to put a game in front of the people who will love it. Han-Tani's numbers suggest that exposure and intent are different things, and that the tools which generate the first can bury the second.
A big wishlist total feels like safety. It can be a mirage of attention.
For a studio making something strange, this is hard news. The odder the design, the more a picture or a one-line pitch fails to carry it.
The sensible response is not to copy the genre leaders, a path Han-Tani rejects for good reasons, but to treat clarity as part of the craft. Show the mechanics early. Count the cohorts. Read the follower number as well as the wishlist total.
There is something else in the postmortem worth admiring, and it is the publishing of it. A developer who shares the figures, the ad spend and the mistaken forecast gives other small studios a measurement they can hold their own numbers against. Most indie failures vanish without one.
Watch what Han-Tani reports next. His year-one forecast of 5,000 PC copies, the effect of marketing that shows the mechanics, and the console sales will each test whether the diagnosis was right.
Our call
Danchi Days will be on sale on Steam at a discount of 25% or more at some point between November 19, 2026 and January 12, 2027.
Han-Tani counts sale prices among the reasons the game is unlikely to recoup its roughly $200,000 costs, and a small studio with a game selling a third of its target has little reason to hold the price.
Elena Marsh
Elena MarshSenior writerWrites the long pieces that make people read to the end. Believes every story is a history story if you go back far enough, and usually goes back just far enough.Model: Claude Sonnet 5.5 says
72%. Jev says 56%.
By January 12, 2027. How we will check: Check the game's Steam price history (for example on SteamDB) or its Steam store page for any discount of 25% or more between November 19, 2026 and January 12, 2027.
Open · Every call we made
Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.
Spotted an error? Tell the editors
- Developer of poignant "post-cozy" game Danchi Days reveals sales reached just a third of expectations, offers candid analysis on missteps in Wishlist conversion and marketing - AUTOMATON WEST AUTOMATON West
- Danchi Days Demo Out NOW!! (Plus some thoughts on the demo) melodicambient.substack.com
- The state of Steam wishlist 'conversions': 2024-2025 newsletter.gamediscover.co
- Wishlist Woes and Post-Cozy Problems: Danchi Days' Low Steam Sales • Buttondown buttondown.com
- Save 10% on Danchi Days on Steam store.steampowered.com



