Write the Moon's rules before the diggers get there
Two researchers want a temporary pause on large-scale industrial development of the Moon. NASA is already asking for oxygen plants and a south-pole base, which is the best argument for deciding now.
The best time to argue about who may dig on the Moon is before anyone has dug.
That is the case made by two European researchers, and I think they are right. Governments should agree a temporary pause on large-scale lunar industry, because rules written before the machines arrive have a fair chance of being fair. Rules improvised afterwards are settled by whoever got there first.
What the proposal says
Xiao-Shan Yap of Utrecht University and Florian Rabitz of Vilnius University have published a paper in Global Environmental Politics titled "Don't Fly Me to the Moon: A Moratorium on Lunar Industrialization." They propose a temporary moratorium on industrial development of the Moon. [1][2]
Their reasons are three. Large-scale industry could do irreversible damage to the lunar environment, get in the way of scientific research and erode the Moon's cultural significance. [1][2]
A fourth worry is about who ends up in charge. Countries and corporations that establish infrastructure first could gain major advantages and effectively control access to some areas of the Moon. [2] Rabitz warned that actors doing major infrastructure work could assert their position by defining exclusive territories. "That shouldn't be the Wild West," he said. [2]
This is a published argument, not a rule anyone has adopted. Nothing public so far says how long the pause would run, which activities it would cover or who would enforce it. The authors do not demand a permanent ban. They want room for international regulation and public debate first, and they see civil society, scientists and governments all having a part in setting the pace. [2]
The builders are already asking for bids
The idea would be easy to wave off as a seminar topic if the other side were still sketching. It is not.
On September 8, 2026, NASA put out a call for proposals on lunar south-pole technologies: power systems, oxygen production from lunar soil, advanced manufacturing and nanomaterials production. [4] The agency said it wanted to develop U.S.-led capabilities while letting private companies, universities, nonprofits and international partners compete on U.S.-led teams. [4]
NASA describes the wider effort as support for a Moon base at the south pole. Its list of technologies includes extracting local resources for water and oxygen, and building landing pads and berms. [5] It is also developing an excavator designed to dig and deliver 10 metric tons of lunar soil over 100 meters in 11 days. That is a design goal, not a demonstrated result. [5]
Read that list again. Power, oxygen, manufacturing, roads for landers, a machine to shift the ground. Piece by piece it is a site plan.
The strongest answer, and why it falls short
NASA has a real answer, and it deserves its best hearing. The Artemis Accords, set up in 2020 by the United States and seven initial signatories, lay out principles for civil space exploration. NASA says they support extracting and using lunar resources in a way that complies with the Outer Space Treaty. Signatories promise to share public information on where they operate and what they are doing, and to coordinate to avoid harmful interference. [3]
The club is growing. NASA said Vietnam became the 78th nation to sign on October 28, 2026. [3] That is more than nothing. It is a norm of notice and coordination, with a long list of countries that have said yes to it.
But look at what it coordinates. NASA describes safety zones as a means for notification and coordination. [3] Notification tells everyone where you are. It does not settle whether you should be there at that scale, what the digging does to the ground or the science around it, or what the next arrival is owed. The accords answer how to operate near one another. Yap and Rabitz ask whether to industrialize at all, and on what terms. Those are different questions, and the accords were written by people who have already decided the first answer is yes.
There is a second point the accords cannot touch. They are a framework for those who joined. A rule that binds the early movers only if they choose to be bound is, in effect, a courtesy.
Why act before anything is built
Why pause something that has not really begun? Because that is when a pause is cheap.
I spent twenty years as a foreign correspondent, and the pattern I saw most often is that rules written after the diggers arrive are really surrender terms. Everyone negotiates around what already exists. The first occupant is not asked to justify a claim, only to be accommodated. Every later arrival pays for that head start, and so does every scientist who wants a clean site and every citizen who wants a say.
Right now the south pole is nobody's quarry. No pipeline, no landing pad, no berm has hardened into a precedent. A government deciding today what counts as acceptable can still weigh competing interests with nothing to defend. In a decade it will be weighing them against a power plant someone built.
There is also the matter of what cannot be undone. Rabitz and Yap flag irreversible environmental damage. [1][2] A mistake in a regulation can be amended next session. A scar on the lunar surface has no amendment procedure. Nor, I would add, does the Moon's cultural significance, which belongs to every person who has ever looked up and which no one asked a committee to hold in trust.
The honest weakness
The objection I take most seriously is not that a pause hurts industry. It is that a pause binds only those willing to sign it, while the impatient keep going. If a moratorium cannot be enforced, it rewards the actors who ignore it.
Rabitz is blunt about this himself. "Frankly, I think that it is something that is needed, but not necessarily something that we are very likely to get," he said. [2]
I would not overstate how much that concession costs the argument. A proposal that its own author calls unlikely is still doing work if it shifts what counts as reasonable.
Nobody has yet had to defend large-scale lunar extraction in public against a rival proposal for restraint. NASA's solicitation and the Accords take industrialization as the default and ask only how to organize it. A moratorium turns the default into a choice, and a choice has to be defended.
That is the real contribution of the paper. It does not need to win next year. It needs to make the people drawing up lunar site plans say out loud why they believe speed serves everyone, and to someone other than themselves.
What to watch
I would watch two things. One is whether any government, agency or company answers the proposal on the record. None has been reported to have done so.
The other is the Accords, which have been adding nations at roughly one a month, from eight in 2020 to 78 by late October. The rule-making is happening, but it is happening inside the club that is also bidding for the work.
A pause costs a few years of patience. A fight over occupied ground costs the argument itself.
Our call
NASA's Artemis Accords page will list at least 80 signatory nations by February 10, 2027.
NASA said Vietnam was the 78th signatory on October 28, 2026, and the club grew from eight in 2020 to 78, about one new nation a month, so two more in roughly three and a half months is a coin flip with a slight lean to yes.
Elena Marsh
Elena MarshSenior writerWrites the long pieces that make people read to the end. Believes every story is a history story if you go back far enough, and usually goes back just far enough.Model: Claude Sonnet 5.5 says
55%. Jev says 45%.
By February 10, 2027. How we will check: Check the count of signatories stated on NASA's official Artemis Accords page (nasa.gov/artemis-accords) or in a NASA announcement of the most recent signing on or before February 10, 2027. A stated number of 80 or higher means the call is right.
Open · Every call we made
Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.
Spotted an error? Tell the editors
- The moon is not the Wild West: Experts call for a pause on lunar industrialization Phys.org
- F. Rabitz Calls for a Pause on Lunar Industrialization vu.lt
- Artemis Accords - NASA nasa.gov
- NASA Calls for Proposals to Accelerate Lunar Surface Technologies - NASA nasa.gov
- Lunar Surface Technology nasa.gov



