The Daily Inference
World · News · Developing

Bahrain Jails 64 for Life in Iran-Linked Case, Rights Group Says

Rights groups say 60 of the 69 defendants are Shi'ite clerics. Bahrain describes an Iranian-backed plot to overthrow the government, while campaigners allege coercion and severe restrictions on the defence.

Developing: this story is still unfolding and details may change.

A Bahraini court has sentenced 64 people to life imprisonment, a rights group said, in a mass prosecution alleging an Iranian-backed conspiracy to overthrow the government. [1]

The Bahrain Institute for Rights and Democracy, known as BIRD, said another five defendants received 15-year prison terms and that 60 of the 69 defendants were Shi'ite clerics. Bahrain's Public Prosecution announced on November 16 that the High Criminal Court had convicted all defendants, some of whom were tried in absentia. [1]

The verdict brings sweeping prison sentences in a case that reaches into religious teaching, charitable funds and ties to Iran. Prosecutors describe those activities as parts of a terrorist organisation. Rights groups say the prosecution risks treating religious practice and identity as evidence of criminal responsibility. [1][2]

The two accounts put different questions at the centre of the case. Bahrain says it has acted against a threat to the state. Human Rights Watch and other organisations say the proceedings were marred by allegations of torture, disputed confessions and restrictions that prevented lawyers from properly examining the evidence. [1][2]

The state's case

According to the Public Prosecution, the defendants established and ran a terrorist group linked to Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the powerful Iranian military organisation commonly known as the IRGC. Prosecutors said the group sought to overthrow Bahrain's government. Those are the state's allegations and the court's reported findings, rather than independently established accounts of the defendants' conduct. [1]

The prosecution accused defendants of raising money without authorisation and using mosques, religious sermons, charitable organisations and educational institutions to promote allegiance to Iran's supreme leader. Its account places institutions used for worship, teaching and giving at the centre of the alleged organisation. [1]

Bahrain's chief of public security, Lieutenant General Tariq al-Hassan, said the security measures targeted activities that threatened national security, rather than Shi'ite citizens because of their faith. Iran has previously rejected Bahraini accusations that it interferes in the country's internal affairs. [4][1]

The financial penalties extend beyond imprisonment. Prosecutors said some defendants were fined 100,000 Bahraini dinars and that the court ordered the confiscation of more than eight million dinars for charitable purposes. [1]

The prison terms reported by BIRD mean that more than nine in every 10 defendants received life sentences. Even the five defendants who did not receive life face 15 years in prison. The figures describe a prosecution whose consequences reach across almost the entire group with comparable severity. [1]

Religious activity under scrutiny

Before the verdict, Human Rights Watch and other rights groups described the case as involving 60 Shi'ite clerics and nine affiliates. They said 56 defendants were in custody and 13 clerics were being tried in absentia. [2]

The clerical majority matters because of the conduct cited against them. Rights groups said accusations rested in part on teaching, possession of religious books, charitable funds and foreign religious contacts. [2]

A prosecution involving religious institutions can still concern genuine criminal conduct. But the state's account requires evidence connecting those activities to the alleged organisation and its purpose. A sermon, a donation or a religious contact does not, by itself, explain how a particular defendant participated in a plot to overthrow a government.

The arrests preceded the judgment by several months. Bahrain detained more than 50 clerics and religious orators between May and June, accusing them of seeking to incite rebellion and overthrow the ruling order with IRGC help, according to Reuters. [1]

Disputed statements and access to evidence

BIRD gathered detainees' allegations of forced standing, prolonged blindfolding and handcuffing, sleep deprivation, and threats against defendants and their families. Human Rights Watch included those allegations in its account of the proceedings before the verdict. They have not been independently established. [2][3]

Human Rights Watch also said defence lawyers were denied meaningful access to evidence and could not obtain copies of the case files. It reported BIRD's account that defendants disputed statements attributed to them and that some purported confessions contained identical passages. [2]

Those allegations challenge the process by which the court reached its findings. Access to the files would allow lawyers to test what each defendant was said to have done.

Disputed statements and repeated passages raise a separate question about how the evidence was produced. The severity of the sentences makes scrutiny of both issues essential.

The full judgment, a defendant-by-defendant sentencing list and the defendants' response to the verdict are not available. It is also not known whether the court addressed the coercion allegations, whether defendants will appeal or what deadlines would apply. The published totals do not specify exactly how many clerics received life terms. [1][2]

Topics: Bahrain · Iran · Human Rights Watch · Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps

Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.

Sources
  1. Scores of Bahraini Shi'ite clerics get life in prison for plotting with Iran | The Straits Times The Straits Times
  2. Bahrain: Shia Clerics Face Mass Trial Marred by Torture Allegations and Grave Fair Trial Violations | Human Rights Watch hrw.org
  3. Rights groups condemn Bahrain's largest mass trial of Shia clerics in history | Middle East Eye middleeasteye.net
  4. Bahrain Postpones Verdict in Trial of 60 Shiite Clerics Accused of IRGC Links | Alhurra alhurra.com