Thursday's ruling could order Myanmar to make reparation to the Rohingya
Seven years after The Gambia brought its case, judges will decide whether Myanmar violated the Genocide Convention against the Rohingya. The ruling could establish state responsibility and order redress, but delivering it will depend on compliance.
The International Court of Justice will rule Thursday on whether Myanmar violated the Genocide Convention against the Rohingya, a decision that could establish responsibility and order redress. [2][3]
The judgment, scheduled for November 19, 2026, comes seven years after The Gambia brought the case. It asks the court to find that Myanmar committed genocide and breached duties to prevent and punish it, and to order remedies for Rohingya victims. [2][3][5]
For survivors, the stakes include recognition of what happened and decisions on demands for safe return, property and family reunification. For governments that signed the convention, the case demonstrates the reach of a shared treaty obligation: The Gambia was entitled to bring it despite having no direct connection to the alleged crimes. [1][3]
This is a case against a state, not a criminal trial of military officers or government officials. Thursday's judgment will be final and cannot be appealed. Its practical effect will depend in part on whether Myanmar obeys it. [3][4]
The court has already rejected Myanmar's objections to hearing the case and issued binding protective orders. Neither decision settled whether genocide occurred. That question, alongside the other alleged treaty breaches, now reaches judgment after both states presented their arguments and evidence in January. [1][2][3]
What the judges must decide
The Rohingya are an ethnic minority in Myanmar. Human Rights Watch says the military campaign in northern Rakhine State in 2017 forced more than 700,000 Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh. That displacement forms part of the history behind the legal battle now reaching its conclusion in The Hague. [3]
The Gambia filed its application on November 11, 2019, invoking the Genocide Convention. Its allegations extend beyond the commission of genocide to failures to prevent and punish it. The judges must therefore decide several questions of state responsibility, rather than give a single answer covering every alleged breach. [3][5]
Genocide has a specific legal meaning. It requires intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected group.
How the judges assess the evidence of that intent will be central to their decision on the genocide allegation. Both Myanmar and The Gambia presented arguments and evidence during the merits hearings, which also included testimony from witnesses and an expert. The hearings ended on January 29. [2][3]
The substance of the judgment is not yet known, including whether the judges will find genocide or another breach, what remedies they might grant, and whether they will address compliance with their earlier protective order. [2][3]
Eleven states were permitted to intervene on limited questions about how to interpret the convention. They did not participate in the merits hearings. Their role concerned the meaning of the treaty, rather than presenting the parties' factual cases. [3]
Why The Gambia could bring the case
Myanmar challenged The Gambia's right to proceed. In July 2022, the court rejected Myanmar's early arguments that it should not hear the case at all, known as preliminary objections. It confirmed its authority to hear the dispute and allowed the case to go forward to a decision on the allegations themselves. [1]
The court held that any state party to the Genocide Convention could invoke another party's responsibility for alleged breaches of obligations owed to all parties. The Gambia did not have to show that it had suffered a special injury of its own. [1]
That ruling gives the case importance well beyond the two governments. Enforcement of the convention need not begin with a neighbouring state, a state receiving refugees or a government whose own citizens were harmed. [1]
The court had already acted to protect the Rohingya while the litigation continued. On January 23, 2020, it ordered Myanmar to take measures to prevent genocidal acts, preserve evidence and report on compliance. Those measures are legally binding on the parties. [3][4][5]
Protective orders serve an immediate purpose while a case is being heard. Thursday is the point at which the court is due to give its judgment on the merits. [2][3]
What a judgment can deliver
If the court finds for The Gambia, it could establish a binding breach of the convention and order Myanmar to comply with its obligations and provide reparation. The scope of any remedy will matter as much to victims as the legal finding itself. [3]
The Gambia has requested measures concerning safe and dignified return, restoration or replacement of property, family reunification, rehabilitation and protection against discrimination. These requests turn an interstate dispute into concrete questions about whether displaced people can recover homes, reconnect with relatives and return safely. [3]
Myanmar has contested The Gambia's entitlement to seek reparations on behalf of Rohingya victims, according to Human Rights Watch. A finding of responsibility would therefore leave the judges with consequential decisions about the relief they grant and who benefits from it. [3]
A judgment against The Gambia would mean the court had not established the violations alleged in this case. It would resolve those legal claims without erasing the history of displacement or determining individual criminal responsibility. [3][4]
The court has no independent force to enforce its decisions. If Myanmar fails to comply, either party may turn to the UN Security Council, which can recommend or decide measures to give effect to the judgment. The Council has never previously used that power to enforce an ICJ judgment, according to Human Rights Watch. [3]
Thursday's first answer will come from the judges: which obligations Myanmar breached, if any, and what it must do as a result. Any orders will then put the next decision before Myanmar - whether to comply with a final, binding judgment. [2][3]
Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.
Spotted an error? Tell the editors
- Judgment of 22 July 2022 | INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE icj-cij.org
- Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (The Gambia v. Myanmar icj-cij.org
- International Court of Justice Judgment in Myanmar Genocide Case | Human Rights Watch hrw.org
- UN World Court begins landmark hearings on Rohingya genocide case against Myanmar | UN News news.un.org
- INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE icj-cij.org




