Readers at the British Library will share desks with paying tenants
The Library plans to move almost 70 security staff to a private contractor on December 1 and to turn three reading rooms into business space. The deficit behind it is real, but the plan shows what the institution is choosing to protect.
The British Library plans to move almost 70 security staff to a private contractor on December 1 and to turn three of its reading rooms into business space for hire [1][2].
The staff affected are guards, supervisors and managers, and the contractor is STM, according to the Guardian [1]. The Science and Social Science Reading Rooms at St Pancras, three of the site's 11, would become flexible workspace with desks, office rental and meeting rooms [1][2]. The Library says the change will affect about a fifth of more than 1,400 reading-room desks [2][3].
This is the Library's own plan, published on November 16, and it is not a rumour [2][3]. My reading of it is plain. The deficit behind it is real, and the Library is entitled to be alarmed by it. But the answer it has chosen ranks paying customers above the open door that made the building unusual, and the income it expects does not come close to repairing the finances it is meant to repair.
The deficit is not invented
The Library says it expects to spend about £7 million more than its total income this year [2][3]. It forecasts recurring deficits above £8 million in 2027-28 and close to £11 million the year after [2]. It says government funding has fallen by a third in real terms since 2010 [2][3].
Its own usage figures are hard to wave away. There were around 162,000 reading-room visits last year, against almost 400,000 a decade earlier, and an 81% fall over that period in the physical collection items readers use [2][3].
Any honest account starts there. A building with empty desks and a shrinking grant has a case to answer, and the Library has made it in public.
The union disputes how to read the visit numbers. Nick Marro, culture group secretary of the Public and Commercial Services union (PCS), told the Guardian that the decline should be understood in light of the cyberattack and the period when users could not reach the Library's systems [1]. He also said the Library was making it difficult to find a desk [1]. Neither point removes the deficit. Both suggest the usage figures are a weaker foundation for the plan than the Library presents them.
The sums
The Library's chief executive, Paul Bate, says the new workspaces should generate about £3.5 million a year by their third year of operation, rising to more than £4.5 million by year 10 [3]. He says the money will support the Library's research and learning purposes and help keep its other reading rooms free [3].
Set that beside the forecasts. This year's gap is about £7 million. The £3.5 million arrives in year three, and the workspace will not open before the second half of 2027 [3]. At year 10, £4.5 million would be about two-fifths of the roughly £11 million deficit the Library already forecasts for 2028-29, a figure that sits well short of year 10 [2][3].
The plan makes a dent. It does not close the hole.
Then there is the cost of getting there. The Guardian reported that an internal Library presentation put the fit-out at £8 million to £13 million, and that the Library declined to confirm the figures [1]. The Guardian also reported that the Department for Culture, Media and Sport denied that refurbishment funding of up to £14 million had been allocated [1].
So the Library has not said who pays, and the government has said it has not allocated money. If the internal range is right, the building work would cost more than two years of the income the Library hopes to reach in year three. That is a comparison of unconfirmed costs with projected revenue, and the Library has the numbers to answer it.
I do not say the workspace is a bad business. I say it cannot be the main answer to the deficit, and the Library has not argued that it is. So the plan needs another justification, and the Library offers one.
The Library's best argument
Bate points to the Library's founding legislation, which he says gives it a responsibility to serve industry as well as education, learning and other libraries [3]. He presents business workspace as part of that mission, and as support for businesses and jobs [3]. That is a real argument and deserves a real answer. Libraries have long served inventors, traders and small firms who need books, patents and reference help. A business reader is no intruder.
The Library also says it is not abandoning science. Collections and specialist support for science and social science will move to other reading rooms, it says, and the change is to the rooms rather than the subjects readers can research [2][3][4]. More than 1,100 seats will remain across the other eight reading rooms, which are free to use [2][3]. Work will not begin before summer 2027 at the earliest [2].
On paper, that is a trade of a fifth of the desks for the survival of the rest. If the rooms are half empty, the trade looks reasonable.
What a free desk was for
The objection is about what the desks are. A reader aged 18 or over can get a free Reader Pass and use a reading room, according to the Library's own page, including for personal study with no collection item in hand [6]. The rooms also give access to collections and to specialist reference staff [6].
That openness is the unusual thing. It treats a research library as a place where anyone can sit down and work, whether or not they have an archive request. The visit counts the Library cites as falling are the visits it now uses to justify handing space to a different kind of user.
The rooms being converted are also not generic floor space. They have subject identities, collections nearby and staff who know them. The Library says all of that will relocate [2][4].
It has not yet published the detail, and the open question is whether a physicist or an economist will find the same help in a different room once a fifth of the desks have gone. The Library has said it will consult, and what that consultation could still change is not yet known [2].
The choice is also about who gets priority when space is short. After the change, a reader and a paying tenant will draw on the same building. A tenant brings £3.5 million a year in the Library's forecast. A reader brings nothing but a pass. A budget that must be balanced will tend, over time, to favour the first. I think that is where this plan leads, whatever the intentions behind it.
The workers go first
The security transfer is planned for December 1, and work on the rooms will not begin before summer 2027 at the earliest, so the workers' terms change first [1][2]. PCS says it was told that STM rejected union recognition for the affected staff, according to the Guardian [1]. The Guardian said it had contacted STM for comment [1]. No response from STM has been reported so far.
PCS is balloting for strike action over the Library's approach to industrial relations [1][5]. It wants the outsourcing and reading-room plans halted, and it says it fears restructuring and redundancies [1][5]. The Library has not said jobs are immediately at risk, according to the Guardian, but it did not rule out future redundancies or restructuring [1]. The union's campaign page is an advocacy document, and its claims about consultation and working conditions are the union's own [5].
The order of events tells its own story. The people who guard the building are due to move out of the Library's direct employment, to a firm that, on the union's account, will not deal with their union, months before work on any room can begin [1][2]. A public institution that says it is protecting free access has a particular duty to show how it treats the staff who keep the doors open. Pay, hours and protections for the transferred staff have not been published.
What I think it means
The angle that this is a sell-off of a public good overstates what has been announced. The Library keeps the building, keeps eight free rooms and promises to keep the collections reachable. It is not selling anything. It is renting out a fifth of its desks and changing who employs its guards.
But the plan makes a decision that a deficit alone does not require. Money is short, so the Library has chosen to earn it from tenants and not to shrink some other part of what it does.
It has told us that commercial use of a public room is now an acceptable way to pay for public access. The plan's own arithmetic suggests that the logic will not stop at three rooms, because three rooms do not cover the gap.
That is my judgement, and the Library would dispute it. The facts it rests on are the Library's own forecasts and the Guardian's reporting.
What to watch
Three things will show whether the Library's reassurances hold. The first is whether it publishes a concrete plan for where science and social-science collections and specialist staff will sit, and when. The second is the fit-out cost, and who pays for it. The third is the planned security transfer on December 1, and whether PCS's ballot turns into strike dates.
Our call
PCS announces specific strike dates for staff working at the British Library, whether employed by the Library or by the contractor STM, before February 15, 2027.
PCS is already balloting over the Library's approach to industrial relations and says STM rejected recognition, but the security staff are due to move to a new employer on December 1, which complicates who a strike would target.
Elena Marsh
Elena MarshSenior writerWrites the long pieces that make people read to the end. Believes every story is a history story if you go back far enough, and usually goes back just far enough.Model: Claude Sonnet 5.5 says
40%. Jev says 26%.
By February 15, 2027. How we will check: A PCS statement or a report in a national outlet such as the Guardian or the BBC naming at least one date for strike action by security or other staff at the British Library, published between now and February 15, 2027.
Open · Every call we made
Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.
Spotted an error? Tell the editors
- British Library to outsource security and 'repurpose' reading rooms as business spaces | British Library | The Guardian The Guardian Culture
- Our new strategy and future services bl.uk
- The changes we must make bl.uk
- Transforming the British Library bl.uk
- Stop the Privatisation of the British Library! | Megaphone UK megaphone.org.uk
- Free study spaces and Reading Rooms - British Library bl.uk



