The Daily Inference
AI & Technology · News · Developing

Two Years of Talks on Killer Robots, and Still No Binding Rules

The Geneva conference launched work on an international instrument without settling whether it will have legal force. The Red Cross says states missed the chance to begin immediate negotiations on a treaty.

Developing: this story is still unfolding and details may change.

Diplomats from 128 states agreed in Geneva to work for two years on an international instrument governing autonomous weapons, without adopting rules or settling its legal force. [4]

The agreement gives the process a next step. It leaves governments divided over whether weapons that select and attack targets without a person deciding each strike should face dedicated, legally binding limits. Existing international humanitarian law, the wartime rules that limit how force may be used and protect civilians, already applies, but there is no specific binding instrument regulating autonomous weapons. [1][2][4]

The five-day review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons ran from November 16 to 20, 2026, at the Palais des Nations. Talks continued into the early hours of November 21 under the presidency of Swiss ambassador Julien Thöni, who described the two-year agreement to reporters. [4][5]

The International Committee of the Red Cross said the conference failed to agree to a clear, immediate mandate to negotiate a legally binding instrument. It wants a treaty that prohibits unpredictable autonomous weapons and those that target humans directly, while restricting other autonomous weapons. [1]

That leaves the most important choice ahead: whether the next two years produce enforceable commitments or an instrument without binding legal force. [1][4]

A mandate short of a treaty

The Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, known as the CCW, is a framework through which states ban or restrict particular conventional weapons. It has 128 parties, and its review conference takes place every five years. This meeting offered governments a chance to decide how the autonomous-weapons process should advance. [5][6]

Nearly 100 countries had called for negotiations on a legally binding agreement, according to Deutsche Welle. The United States, Russia and Israel were among the countries opposing that mandate, it said. [4]

The Red Cross said the overwhelming majority of states that voiced support during the talks backed negotiations. It also urged governments to act on a call supported by 163 states in a resolution approved by the UN General Assembly's First Committee the previous month. [1]

Those figures measure different groups: support expressed at the Geneva talks and support for a resolution in the broader UN process. Neither translated into an immediate mandate for binding negotiations at the conference. [1]

The unresolved legal status is part of the compromise, not a detail to be completed after the substantive work.

A binding treaty would commit its parties to legal obligations. A nonbinding instrument could set out shared principles without creating the same treaty duties. Which route governments choose will determine what their agreement demands of them.

The detailed arrangements for negotiating sessions, deadlines and any mandate to draft a protocol are not yet clear. The broad outcome establishes two years of work, with the instrument's legal form and its eventual prohibitions or restrictions still undecided. [1][4]

The decision inside the weapon

The UN's working description focuses on three functions: identifying a target, selecting it and engaging it. A weapon capable of performing those functions without human intervention falls within that description. Programming possible targets in advance does not automatically put a system outside it. [2]

The practical question is where the human decision ends. A person may set a weapon's parameters before it operates, yet the system may still select and attack a target without that person deciding on the particular strike. The negotiations concern that transfer of decisions about force to a machine. [2]

A drone is not automatically an autonomous weapon. A remotely controlled armed drone can remain under a person's direction. Equally, autonomy does not require artificial intelligence, and it is a function rather than a particular kind of aircraft, vehicle or other platform. [2]

These distinctions matter for any workable agreement. Rules written around a familiar shape, such as a drone, would fail to address the full question. The relevant feature is what the weapon can decide and do without human intervention.

The Red Cross's proposals make that concern concrete. Its call to prohibit unpredictable systems addresses whether people can anticipate and control a weapon's effects. Its proposed prohibition on weapons targeting humans directly addresses who or what the machine is permitted to select. Other autonomous weapons would face restrictions rather than a blanket prohibition. [1]

This is therefore a debate about several kinds of limits, not simply a vote for or against every weapon with an autonomous function. The eventual instrument could distinguish between systems that states would prohibit and those they would permit under restrictions. That is the approach the Red Cross is urging. [1]

A deadline gives way to two years of work

The UN and the Red Cross had called for a legally binding instrument by 2026. In their joint appeal on August 25, they identified the November review conference as the clearest available route to advance negotiations. [3][5]

Preparatory work had already supplied material for governments to consider. An experts' report adopted by consensus in September set out elements of a possible instrument and recommended that states decide on future work. It deliberately did not prejudge whether the instrument should be legally binding. [5]

The agreement is progress in procedure. Its value will depend on whether governments use those two years to settle limits they are willing to accept, rather than preserve the same disagreement in a longer document.

The next task for the 128 states is to turn the agreed work programme into an instrument. The Red Cross is pressing them to give that work a binding mandate and negotiate prohibitions and restrictions. [1][4]

Topics: United Nations · International Committee of the Red Cross

Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.

Sources
  1. ICRC renews urgent call for legally binding rules on autonomous weapons after failure to launch negotiations | International Committee of the Red Cross icrc.org
  2. Autonomous Weapon Systems: Frequently Asked Questions | United Nations un.org
  3. UN chief, Red Cross renew call for rules on lethal autonomous weapons | UN News ungeneva.org
  4. 'Killer robots' talks at UN end with no legally binding ban dw.com
  5. Seventh Review Conference of the High Contracting Parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) | The United Nations Office at Geneva ungeneva.org
  6. Seventh Review Conference of the High Contracting Parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) | The United Nations Office at Geneva ungeneva.org