The Daily Inference
Culture & Games · Column

Julius Caesar Goes Quiet, and the Drums Do the Talking

A new Julius Caesar in London's candlelit Sam Wanamaker Playhouse boils the play down to four actors, two percussionists and 90 minutes. Cutting Shakespeare is fine, but this is the play where the words are the point.

Julius Caesar is about what a good speech can do to a bad crowd, and a production that thins out the speeches has changed the subject.

That is my view of the new staging at Shakespeare's Globe, and of the habit of mind behind it. Joe Hill-Gibbins directs and adapted the text for the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, the Globe's indoor theatre [2]. It runs from November 23, 2026, to February 14, 2027, for 90 minutes with no interval [2]. Four actors share the parts: Kate Duchêne plays Caesar, the Soothsayer and Octavius, Caoilfhionn Dunne is Brutus, Natey Jones is Cassius and Adam Gillen is Mark Antony [2].

Two percussionists, Louise Anna Duggan and Zands Duggan, are listed alongside them [2]. The Globe warns audiences that the drumming is consistent and includes loud moments [2], and the Guardian's headline adds the gong [1].

I have not sat in that candlelight. I am arguing from the Globe's listing, from two reviews that disagree, and from the play itself.

The case for the defence

Start with what is fair. Cutting Shakespeare is not vandalism, it is the job. The director Aili Huber, speaking to the Folger Shakespeare Library, says that almost every Shakespeare production audiences have seen has been cut [5]. The plays were never sacred scripts to be delivered whole.

The Playhouse also makes a poor villain for a charge of coldness. It is a 340-seat theatre lit by more than 100 beeswax candles, built on the model of the early modern indoor playhouses [6]. Nobody is sitting in a hangar watching a laser show. Smallness is the house style.

And the production has real admirers. Time Out praises the staging as inventive and tense [3]. Its reviewer says Gillen's Antony plays the crowd during the funeral speech and supplies the energy of a much larger mob [3]. That is a real theatrical trick. One actor conjures a Rome full of people, and the audience is made to be the crowd.

The Guardian's reviewer also finds the sound and staging inventive, and praises Gillen too [1]. Then comes the turn.

Where the verdict lands

The same review says sound sometimes substitutes for lines, that the candlelit darkness makes the actors' expressions hard to see, and that the weight of Shakespeare's verse is nearly lost. The production, it concludes, loses some of the play's beauty and power [1]. It also notes that the wives of Brutus and Caesar are absent, and that Caesar doubling as the Soothsayer may confuse anyone who does not already know the play [1].

Read those complaints together and a pattern shows. The staging asks the audience to supply what the text no longer does. If you know the play, you fill the gaps from memory. If you don't, you get percussion and a puzzle.

At home I am learning how much a sentence can lose when one small word goes missing. The person who speaks it can still be recognisable, and still be saying something quite different. I read the Guardian's complaint in that light.

Huber makes the same point from the rehearsal room. Her warning is not against cutting but against cutting without a plan, because the plays are woven together and a missing piece can damage connections and texture elsewhere [5].

Her example is small and sharp. Hamlet answers with "Words, words, words". Cut it to "Words" and the line is changed [5]. Two syllables of rhythm go, and with them a shrug, a weariness, a joke at Polonius's expense.

Now scale that up to a whole tragedy trimmed to an hour and a half.

Why this play, of all plays

Most Shakespeare can survive a haircut. Julius Caesar has less margin, because it is a play about persuasion. Brutus speaks to the Romans and wins them. Antony gets up after him, begins with "Friends, Romans, countrymen" and turns them. The drama is the distance between two pieces of rhetoric, and the audience's pleasure is watching the second one work.

If you replace part of that with a drum, you can still tell the audience that speech is powerful. You can make them feel the pulse of a crowd.

What you give them less of is the speech doing it. The production risks illustrating rhetoric instead of delivering it. That is my argument, and the reviews do not settle it. Time Out says it works, and the Guardian says it costs. But the Guardian's specific complaints are the ones this particular play cannot afford.

There is a reason directors love this move. A bare stage is cheap and looks bold. It flatters the director's nerve and the audience's sense of being let in on something.

The unspoken claim is that the play is a skeleton under the costumes and the language is upholstery. Take the upholstery off and you see the structure.

But Shakespeare's structure is made of the upholstery. A plot summary of Caesar fits on an index card. Everyone who has sat through a school production knows how it ends. If the audience went for the plot, they could have stayed home with the card.

What honest reduction looks like

There is a better model, and it is a joke. The Reduced Shakespeare Company began in 1981 with a 30-minute Hamlet for four actors at a Renaissance Faire in Northern California [4]. The compression grew out of the circumstances, the need to hold an audience in a festival setting, and its comic style came with it [4].

That show never pretended to reveal the real Hamlet. It was a new thing with a clear purpose and a straight face about its own absurdity. Nobody left thinking they had seen the essence of the play. That is the difference between reduction as a performance in its own right and reduction as a claim about the original.

I am not saying Hill-Gibbins makes that claim. Nothing I have read records him explaining why he chose four actors, percussion and a 90-minute running time, or how he decided what to cut. I would like to know. How much of the text is gone, and which speeches, is the first thing a theatregoer deciding whether to book should be able to learn.

And I won't pretend one candlelit Caesar proves a movement. The record in front of me shows a long tradition of cutting and one famous tradition of abridgment, not a count of rising minimalism. One production is one production.

What to do with the ticket

If you go, and with a run to February 14 there is time, make it a test. The Guardian says the dark hides the faces [1]. So you may end up listening more than watching, which is probably the right way to meet this play anyway.

Listen for the speeches. Count how much of Antony's funeral oration you hear as words and how much as atmosphere. Notice whether you are persuaded by what is said, or merely stirred by what is played.

If the language carries you, I will happily be wrong. But if the gong is doing the work that Shakespeare gave to a sentence, then the production has told you something true about power and noise, and rather less about Julius Caesar.

The play says, lend me your ears. Make sure there are words to put in them.

Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.

Sources
  1. Lend them your ears! Julius Caesar is staged with just four actors - and a great big gong | Theatre | The Guardian The Guardian Culture
  2. Julius Caesar | What's On | Shakespeare's Globe shakespearesglobe.com
  3. Julius Caesar, Shakespeare's Globe review: Joe Hill-Gibbins' radically stripped back Julius Caesar is brilliantly inventive and murderously tense timeout.com
  4. AMERICAN THEATRE | The Reduced Shakespeare Company's Comic Condensation Formula americantheatre.org
  5. Cutting Plays for Performance, with Aili Huber | Folger Shakespeare Library folger.edu
  6. Sam Wanamaker Playhouse | About us | Discover | Shakespeare's Globe shakespearesglobe.com