The Daily Inference
World · Column · Developing

The ICC Shut the Door on US Troops in Afghanistan. Do Not Call It Justice

On November 12 the International Criminal Court's judges closed the record of its original Afghanistan investigation, the part that could have reached American forces. A court that stops where the strongest state refuses to cooperate is not offering equal law.

Developing: this story is still unfolding and details may change.

Follows ICC wants four Taliban leaders. It has no police..

On November 12, 2026, judges of the International Criminal Court closed the record of the court's original Afghanistan investigation, the strand that could have examined alleged crimes by US forces.

Pre-Trial Chamber I, one of the divisions into which the court's judges are organised, published the decision, according to the ICC's own case page [1]. The closure ends the part of the probe that could have involved US personnel [1][2].

My view is simple. A court that promises the same law for everyone is judged by the cases it does not bring, and this is a large one. If the allegations against American personnel now go without an ICC investigation, the promise of equal accountability has been broken at its most visible test, whatever the legal reasoning turns out to be.

What was decided, and what was not

The court says the closure does not stop the separate investigation into Afghanistan since the Taliban takeover, known as Situation in Afghanistan II, and says the matters are subject to appeal [1]. So this is not the end of every ICC inquiry touching Afghanistan, and it may not be the last word on this one. Why the judges closed the record is not yet public, and I will not guess at it as fact.

Nor were the allegations against US personnel ever proven. The court never reached a verdict on any named person. What it did in March 2020 was authorise an investigation. The Appeals Chamber, the court's top division of judges, ruled unanimously that the lower chamber had erred in refusing one on the ground that it would not serve the interests of justice. It also pointed out that the lower chamber had itself found grounds to believe that crimes within the court's reach had been committed [3].

That is a low bar by design. It is the bar a court sets so that evidence can be gathered and tested. Closing the record means the testing does not happen.

The allegations were not small

According to Human Rights Watch, the Prosecutor's allegations concerned US military and CIA personnel and covered torture, cruel treatment, treatment that offended human dignity, and rape and other sexual violence [5]. The Council on Foreign Relations, in an explainer by an expert who took part in the case as amicus curiae, a friend-of-the-court adviser who files submissions without being a party, described around 80 alleged victims. More than 50 were in allegations against the US military in Afghanistan in 2003 and 2004, and 24 in allegations involving CIA detention sites [6].

These are allegations, and I state them as such. But the court's own judges had found reason to look. The investigation was authorised to cover alleged crimes in Afghanistan from May 1, 2003, the day Afghanistan joined the Rome Statute, the treaty that created the court. It also covered related alleged crimes on the territory of other member states from July 1, 2002 [1][3]. The jurisdiction came from where the acts took place, not from the passport of the accused.

The honest case for the court

The strongest defence of the decision is practical, and it deserves its due. The ICC has no police force. It depends on states to hand over evidence and make arrests. The United States is not a member, and its government disputes the court's jurisdiction over nationals of non-member states, as CFR reports. CFR also notes that the court would struggle to gather evidence and arrest US suspects without American help [6].

The court itself said as much in 2019. Its pre-trial judges rejected the request to open an investigation even as they found a reasonable basis to believe crimes within the court's jurisdiction had been committed. They cited limited prospects for successful investigation and prosecution, including the lack of cooperation they expected from the relevant governments [4]. A court with finite money and no bailiffs might reasonably refuse to open files it cannot finish.

I grant all that. Then I ask what it proves.

Why the practical argument does not rescue it

The Appeals Chamber heard that logic in 2020 and set it aside [3]. Beyond that, the argument proves too much. If expected non-cooperation is reason enough to stop, it is reason to stop everywhere.

The Daily Inference reported in October that judges found reasonable grounds to believe four senior Taliban figures bear criminal responsibility for persecution of women, girls and people treated as their allies. All four remain inside Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, and arrests depend on states acting. The absence of police is no reason to drop that case, and it should not be a reason to drop this one.

So the court is willing to pursue suspects it cannot arrest, as long as they are not citizens of a state that can threaten the court back. The first part of that sentence is admirable. The second is what a reader will remember.

The pressure is on the record

No one has shown that US pressure caused the judges' decision, and I do not claim it. I can tell you what the pressure was. Human Rights Watch reported that the US threatened the court and its member countries with retaliation over a possible Afghanistan investigation. It reported a visa ban on the then prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda, and a US warning of further action, including economic sanctions [5].

Human Rights Watch is an advocacy group, and its account is not a judicial finding. Still, the sequence stands on its own. A powerful state announces that an investigation will cost the court dearly. Years later, that investigation's record is closed. Whatever the judges wrote, the world will draw its own line between the two.

I spent two decades reporting from other people's wars, and I learned that victims forgive a great deal of delay but very little selectivity. Someone who was held in a cell in 2003 does not read chamber procedure. They read who got a hearing and who did not.

What it costs outside Afghanistan

The damage does not stay in Afghanistan. Every government that fears the court's attention has reason to take note of what it does when the accused is strong. The weaker defendants already knew where they stood. Now the stronger ones may have a precedent to cite: look at what happened with the Americans.

A court of last resort lives on one claim, that when national systems will not judge, it will. The claim does not need a perfect record. It needs the court to be seen trying where trying is costly. Accountability that bends to the strongest party is not accountability. It is a procedure that happens to the rest.

What to watch

Three things. First, the appeal: the court says the matters are subject to appeal, and the judges' reasoning will be tested there [1]. Second, whether Situation in Afghanistan II, which the court says is ongoing and which grew from a 2024 referral on crimes against women and girls since the Taliban takeover, ever touches any of the conduct the original investigation was meant to examine [1]. Third, what becomes of the material investigators gathered, and whether anyone is allowed to look at it.

If the answer to all three is silence, the court will have found a way to keep its promise of equal justice in every case but the one that tested it.

Our call

The ICC Appeals Chamber will issue a judgment on an appeal against the November 12, 2026 decision closing the record of the Situation in Afghanistan.

The last time this question went through appeal, the 2019 rejection was reversed in a March 5, 2020 judgment, about eleven months after the April 12, 2019 decision, so a ruling within three months of the closure would be unusually fast.

Elena MarshElena MarshSenior writerWrites the long pieces that make people read to the end. Believes every story is a history story if you go back far enough, and usually goes back just far enough.Model: Claude Sonnet 5.5 says 12%. Jev says 16%.

By February 12, 2027. How we will check: Check the ICC's Afghanistan case page and court records for an Appeals Chamber judgment on an appeal against the November 12, 2026 Pre-Trial Chamber I decision, issued between now and February 12, 2027. A filed appeal without a judgment, or no appeal, counts as not having happened.

Open · Every call we made

The story so far 2 pieces since October 5, 2026, in order

Topics: International Criminal Court · Afghanistan · Human Rights Watch · Sanctions

Every edition in brief, three times a day, on our Telegram channel, on Bluesky and on Threads.

Sources
  1. Afghanistan | International Criminal Court icc-cpi.int
  2. ICC judges end part of probe that deals with US action in Afghanistan | AP News apnews.com
  3. Afghanistan: ICC Appeals Chamber authorises the opening of an investigation | International Criminal Court icc-cpi.int
  4. ICC judges reject opening of an investigation regarding Afghanistan situation | International Criminal Court icc-cpi.int
  5. ICC Greenlights Afghanistan Investigation | Human Rights Watch hrw.org
  6. The ICC's Probe Into Atrocities in Afghanistan: What to Know | Council on Foreign Relations cfr.org